2013:
- Preston Scott- Alderson Broaddus

2014:
- Collin Young- Cornerstone University 

2015:
- Jerry King- UNOH

- Nik Hutton- UNOH

2016:
- Trevor Monk- Walsh University

- Ty Spires- Emory & Henry College

2018:
- Avery Baker- Notre Dame College

- Brandon Barnette- Capital University

- Jaden Jones- Otterbein University 

- Anthony Selhorst- Evangel University

2019:
- Tyler Monk- Tusculum University 

- Spencer Knight- Capital University

- Garrett Davis- Northwood University 

- Jake Jubach- Wilmington College

2020:
- Casey Finck- Penn State University 

- Evan Sines- Eastern Michigan University 

- Wes Ward- Youngstown State University

- Brendan Hutton- Marietta University 

2021:
- Noah Blecha- Muskingum University 

2022:
- Riley Poston- Thomas More University 

- Keegan Montgomery- Alma University 

- Tony Falvo- Shippensburg University

- Layton O'Rourke- Tri-C College

- Ajay Locke- Ohio Northern (football & Wrestling)

2023:
- 

2018 3B/1B Avery Baker, Notre Dame College